Mortgage Insurance vs. Life Insurance: Which is Better? (2022 Guide)

When it comes to mortgage insurance vs. life insurance, which is the better choice? 

Term life insurance can give you the same protection as mortgage life insurance, with more flexibility and at a lower cost.  Let’s get into the reasons why it’s a better choice for most Canadian families.

Mortgage insurance vs. life insurance: what’s the difference?

Both mortgage life insurance and term life insurance can protect your spouse and kids in the unlikely event you pass away. Here are the key differences between these two types of insurance. 

What is mortgage life insurance?

What is term life insurance?

  • Term life insurance is a type of policy you can buy through an insurance company.
  • You decide how long you want your policy to last (typically 10, 20, or 30 years) and how much coverage you need.
  • People usually choose their coverage amount based on their current and future financial obligations, like their mortgage and other debt, as well as the cost of raising their kids and putting them through school.

Recommended reading:
what is term life insurance in Canada?

“This is a key difference between mortgage life insurance and term insurance,” says Laura McKay, Certified Life Insurance Advisor and COO & Co-Founder of PolicyMe. “With mortgage life insurance, the death benefit is paid to the bank, and your family doesn’t ever see the money. “

Learn more about term life insurance in our post or watch the video below to learn about how term life is different from mortgage life insurance.

How long do mortgage life insurance and life insurance last?

In other words, it depends. Mortgage insurance will last as long as you owe money on your home (20-30 years), while you can choose how long your term life insurance policy will last.

What do mortgage life insurance and term life insurance cover?

Both mortgage life insurance and term life insurance cover different things. While they both pay out a benefit in the unlikely event that you pass away, there are some key differences.

  • The amount of the mortgage life insurance benefit will be equal to whatever the remaining balance on your mortgage is, which means it decreases over time as you’re paying it off.
  • It  can only be used to pay off your mortgage.

Term life insurance

  • The amount of your benefit from term life insurance doesn’t change during the course of your policy.
  • The money can be used according to your family's wishes; it can cover the balance on your mortgage, help with funeral expenses, pay for private school, handle medical costs or go into a retirement fund for your spouse.

 Term life insurance allows your family to use the money in any way they’d like. For example, they may choose to pay off the mortgage or use the money to pay for a child’s university tuition. It gives your family flexibility to use the money in the way that makes the most sense.

PolicyMe combines flexibility and affordability to offer some of the most competitive rates in Canada, making term life insurance accessible and available to everyone across the country.

Our online rate calculator makes it easy to compare our rates against mortgage insurance premiums and determine if PolicyMe is right for you.

Use our online tool to get a no-obligation quote and start your application in less time than it takes to reheat your leftovers.

How much does mortgage insurance cost in Canada?

How much mortgage insurance costs depend on your age and the amount of money that you owe on your mortgage

The older you are, the more expensive your premiums will be. Same goes for the mortgage amount. The more you owe, the more they’ll charge you for premiums.

Mortgage life insurance premiums aren’t underwritten, meaning they don’t consider your individual risk. So even if you’re a healthy person without high-risk hobbies, you will likely overpay for insurance if you choose a mortgage insurance policy.

Definition of underwriting for article about mortgage insurance vs term life insurance that reads: "What is underwriting? It's the process of v erifying your health and lifestyle history to make sure you're eligible for the coverage. The underwriter measures the risk of insuring you through checking if you're of average health for your age. Underwriting makes sure all policies are guaranteed to be paid out, premiums are as low as they can be and covers as many people as possible."

An important note on mortgage life insurance cost: it stays the same, regardless of the amount of your mortgage balance. 

This means that as you pay off your mortgage the death benefit decreases but your premiums stay the same. 

Cost of term life insurance

Unlike mortgage life insurance, term life insurance is underwritten. The insurer will consider your individual risk when setting your premiums. Assuming you’re not a smoker or a skydiver, your premiums will cost less than the “one size fits all” rates used with mortgage life insurance.

When you enter into a term life insurance policy, the premium will stay the same for the length of the term, as will the death benefit.

This is different from mortgage insurance, where the premium stays the same for the length of the mortgage, but the benefit gets smaller.

Half of parents who don’t have term life insurance haven’t bought it because they think it’s too expensive, which is an understandable concern. After all, parents juggle a million financial responsibilities.

But there’s a perception that life insurance costs more than it actually does. At PolicyMe, we’ve cut unnecessary steps and costs you'd get with traditional insurers to offer the most affordable product in Canada, with the same quality life insurance coverage.

With expenses like daycare, bills and your future to consider, you want to avoid spending more on insurance than you have to.

Comparing costs of mortgage and term life insurance

Life insurance is important and worth investing in. That said, you don’t want to overpay for your coverage. Here’s a breakdown of how the cost for mortgage life insurance and life insurance policies are set.  

Take a look at the graph below and it becomes pretty clear that the value of mortgage life insurance goes down over time. Not a great deal, is it? 

Chart detailing the differences between mortgage and term life insurance policy coverage

Do I need a medical exam for mortgage insurance?

A medical exam is not needed for mortgage insurance. “One of the selling points of mortgage life insurance is that it’s easy to get,” says Laura. “That’s because the policy isn’t based on a health assessment or any evaluation of your individual risk.”

The drawback to this approach? The life insurance company assumes everyone has the same risk (high) and charges premiums accordingly.

Chart detailing rates for mortgage insurance vs term life insurance underwriting

With PolicyMe, you may not require a medical exam, either. Most eligible applicants don’t require additional medical follow-ups. Of course, some folks need a medical before getting approved, but we make it convenient, quick and easy. And we cover all the costs, so you don’t have to.

Understandably, some people wish to avoid getting a medical, but it can save you a large chunk of change over the course of your policy term.

What happens with mortgage insurance and term life insurance if you change mortgage providers?

If you change mortgage providers, your current mortgage insurance policy will end.

It’s common to move your mortgage from one company to another when your term is up, so it’s important to remember your mortgage insurance won’t transfer over.

You’ll have to set up a new mortgage life insurance policy tied to your new mortgage. And since you’ll be older, rates are likely to be higher.

In contrast, because term life insurance isn’t tied to your mortgage, it isn’t affected when you change mortgage providers.

Is mortgage insurance a good idea?

It’s a good idea to have a financial safety net that will pay off your mortgage if you pass away. However, that doesn’t necessarily require mortgage insurance. For many families, term life insurance can serve this need and is the better choice. Term policies are more affordable and pay out directly to your beneficiaries, who can use the money for the mortgage or their needs as they see fit.

For some people, an existing medical condition can make it difficult to get term life insurance. If that’s your case, mortgage life insurance might make sense.

Because insurers usually don’t perform detailed health assessments for mortgage life insurance, you’re more likely to get approved. 

To learn about different types of mortgages, read our comprehensive guide on Fixed vs Variable Mortgages.

Life insurance vs mortgage insurance in Canada: real-life example

Cayleigh and Adam, who own an architectural firm in Calgary, are raising three-year-old twins.

The couple just bought their first house, a three-bedroom bungalow in the neighbourhood where Cayleigh grew up.

Parents holding toddler by the hands for article about the mortgage  vs. term life insurance

Cayleigh and Adam are concerned about the size of their mortgage, especially if something were to happen to one of them. As it stands, they need both of their incomes from the business to make the monthly payments and provide for their twins. 

They’re considering two options: 

Option 1: Buy the mortgage life insurance sold through their financial institution. Their premiums will conveniently be added to their mortgage payment. The downside is that as they pay off their mortgage in the coming years, their premiums will stay the same, even though the amount paid out to pay off their mortgage is going down.

Option 2: Buy a 20-year term life insurance policy that covers them for the amortization period of their mortgage. If something happens to one of them during that time and the mortgage is largely paid off, they can use the extra money to fund the twins’ education. 

Realizing they don’t need mortgage life insurance, they say no to the bank and buy a term life insurance policy. Their PolicyMe premiums are a little under $30/month each, about the same as they would spend on a dinner out.

See for yourself how affordable life insurance can be. Try our online rate calculator to get a no-obligation quote!

In summary: term life insurance makes sense for most Canadian families

If you have a mortgage and a young family, having some coverage for your mortgage is a good idea.

Because of the flexibility of term life insurance, it's the best move for most Canadian families who own homes.

“With mortgage life insurance, your premiums stay the same, while the benefit paid out decreases as you pay off your mortgage,” says Laura.

“You’re locked in, it’s expensive, and only covers one thing—your mortgage. Not your family.”

Want to compare term life insurance to other types? See our guide on term versus whole life insurance.

FAQs: Life insurance vs. mortgage insurance in Canada

 Do I need mortgage insurance if I have life insurance?

In general, you won’t need mortgage insurance if you have a traditional life insurance policy. When you decide how much coverage you need, you’ll usually include your most significant expenses in the calculation, and that’s likely your mortgage.

And while nothing's stopping you from having two policies, paying two monthly premiums can be expensive and unnecessary.

Does mortgage insurance pay a death benefit?

Mortgage insurance pays out the remainder owing on your mortgage if you pass away. So in that sense, it does pay a death benefit. But the money won’t go to your family or beneficiaries. Instead, it goes directly to the bank to cover the balance owed on your home.

If you’re looking for life insurance that will deliver a payout to your loved ones and provide them with financial support after your passing, you will need to purchase a traditional life insurance policy, like a term life plan.

What happens to life insurance if the mortgage is paid?

Nothing happens to a term life insurance plan if your mortgage is paid off. You’ll continue paying the same premiums, and your death benefit will remain the same. If you pass away after fully paying off your home, your family will have more money for their other needs and living expenses.

In contrast, a mortgage insurance policy ends when the mortgage is paid off. With no active coverage, there’s also no payout if you pass away.

Laura McKay

COO & Co-Founder

About the Author

What to read next